I’ve recently read a post from a Conference WCA group that offered a real and honest perspective, worthy of attention. The post called for resistance to the harm caused by the #resistharm movement, claiming that the “liberal theology” behind this movement is “causing untold harm to hundreds of thousands of wonderful people around the world…by promoting a lifestyle that rebels against the known will of God,” a God who does not “bless unholy or unrepentant people.” As a supporter of #resistharm, I would like to enter into conversation with this perspective.
While I don’t presume to speak for all, I can confidently use the plural when I say that we are not here to promote some secular agenda. As a church, we ask different questions: “How do we respond faithfully to anyone who desires to live as a follower of Christ and grow in relationships of faithfulness and love?” Many of us are asking, “Is it faithful to assess certain people based solely on the way they identify rather than on their character and calling, faithfulness and fruitfulness?” “Do we welcome some by saying they need to change in ways that we don’t ask others to change?” “Is it possible to develop a serious sexual ethic based not on identity, but on the virtues to which we are all called – monogamy, faithfulness, forgiveness and grace? “Rather than judging some as ‘incompatible,’ would it not be more faithful to focus on forms of sexual immorality that objectify others for personal pleasure and cause so much harm in the world?” In short, how do we promote true holiness? We believe that the Holy Spirit is involved in this kind of questioning and is calling us to honor the struggle and to learn how to love one another in the midst of so many diverse expressions of faithfulness and fruitfulness. We believe that this process of struggling and learning is a lifestyle that truly glorifies God. I would even call it traditional – and certainly deeply rooted in Scripture.
With this desire to cultivate lifestyles of faithfulness, we do use the language of LGBTQ, with some adding A and I and +. This language seems to cause much holy discomfort. Why this language? We use the language as a way to express our hope that the church to be a safe place for people to engage in personal and spiritual discernment and find themselves welcomed into a lifestyle of glorifying God through Christ our Lord. We use the language to acknowledge that suppression of this kind of discernment is not healthy and is in fact harmful. The letters themselves are fluid and are there to help people discern who they are as uniquely blessed children of God. For example, I can embrace the letter “A,” as an “ally,” wanting to stand with those who are being harmed. This is one way this letter is used. With the guidance of the Holy Spirit, I am working on changing my understand of the term “Queer,” and learning to honor those who use this word to acknowledge that they are “different” and stand outside the sphere of what is deemed culturally normal, often without being a direct reference to sexuality. Some might say that this is the calling of the whole church.
Using this language as a tool for discernment is very different from using it to label others and assess their status in the larger community. That’s what we want to overcome. We long for the day when we get beyond labeling some siblings in Christ with letters, and colors, and references to gender, in ways that hold some to a different standard, outside the inner circle of those who are privileged and who do NOT feel the pressure to qualify and justify themselves in this way. Faithfulness demands that we resist this particular kind of “evil, injustice, and oppression.”
For one more clarification, I do not accept that “liberal theology” is to blame. I see “liberal” as another charged word used to characterize others as one-dimensional and thus lacking in life-giving truth. As sinful and limited creatures, we need more from each other than that. While seeing through a mirror dimly, and in great need of the perspective of others, my theology is rooted in Christ, in Scripture, in the Creeds, in Wesley, and with a heart that wants to promote holiness defined, with Wesley, by the virtues of humility, patience, and kindness. Through my theological lens, I do not believe it is right to use God and the holy Scriptures as cover to protect our own privilege and conceal our own prejudices. If I ever do that (and I do have blind spots that would make it possible), I hope others in the body of Christ will call me to repentance.
Oh, how I wish we could take the opportunity we are being given to share a positive witness to the world based on all the things in which we could find agreement, liberally sharing the love of Christ and the high and holy calling that we all have been given: to bear one another with a love that is humble, patient, and kind, seeking unity of spirit in the bond of peace (Eph 4:1-3). I believe with all my heart that such a lifestyle would glorify God and be a much better witness to the world.
5 thoughts on “Resisting Harmful Lifestyles”
Amen! Thank you, Michael.
Amen. Thank you. Beautifully written.
Here is the thing, nobody is being judged as incompatible. Homosexuality is being judged as incompatible. Homosexuality is sin, it is not an identity. Why is it that this group of people demand to be identified by their sin instead of calling it for what it is? That is the main issue. They are not being excluded for who they are, they are being excluded for who they are not. Repentant Christians.
It is also wrong to say that repentance is not expected of everyone. It is. But other people are not trying to force their sin into the mainstream and force others to say it is not actually sin but beautiful and acceptable and just the way they are.
Once again, you’re offering a perspective that is thoughtful, articulate and without demonizing those who would disagree. Well done and Thank you!
Thank you for your thoughtful words. I can no more change my orientation – the way God created me – than I can change my eye color without resorting to the “mask” of colored contact lenses that left in too long will cause me great physical harm. LGBTQ+ Christians, including Methodists, are being greatly harmed. Many have left churches and refuse to return due to the bitter remembrance of the wolf in sheep’s clothing aka hate veiled as love. Others have masked themselves so they can attend church without harassment while slowly dying emotionally. We are no more incompatible with Christianity than the opposite gender couple married 50 years. I know this frightens some who just don’t understand why something is now so public that used to only be spoken of in hushed, judgmental whispers. I’ve heard a lot about “agendas” being forced. Yet we are the ones being forced to turn elsewhere for marriages and full inclusion (though our tithes and offerings are always welcomed by everyone). I have LGBTQ+ friends who have been forced from their various churches of various denominations! We are ALL God’s children, loved by God, and blessed by God. Isn’t that an amazing thing?